
There’s a reason A Christmas Carol has been adapted so many times over the years. It’s a classic holiday ghost story wrapped in the themes of redemption and inner goodness, themes that still resonate today. Ebenezer just so happens to be the latest version of Charles Dickens’s classic, directed now by horror filmmaker Ti West and starring Johnny Depp. Ebenezer explores Scrooge’s story by taking a few liberties with the source material and effectively leaning into the gothic atmosphere of Victorian London.
As Ebenezer Scrooge, Depp certainly looks the part thanks to some heavy prosthetics. Occasionally, at certain angles, I saw a bit of George C. Scott’s Scrooge in his appearance. But as for his performance, it’s about what you would expect from Depp. He’s eccentric and theatrical, which works in certain situations, like when he’s barking at his beleaguered clerk, Bob Cratchit (Rupert Grint), but occasionally he comes dangerously close to becoming a caricature. This, I feel, has been a consistent problem with Depp since the first Pirates of the Caribbean movie.
Thankfully Ebenezer boasts a pretty strong supporting cast. Ian McKellen is wonderfully gruff and menacing as Jacob Marley, and scene-stealer Tramell Tillman gives The Ghost of Christmas Present an aggressive edge. Rupert Grint brings plenty of warmth and humanity to Bob Cratchit, though I wish we had seen more of his interactions with Tiny Tim to heighten the emotional stakes. I feel as though both characters didn’t get enough screen time.
I will say that I really enjoyed Andrea Riseborough as The Ghost of Christmas Past. So many adaptations make this particular spirit almost angel-like, but there’s a very eerie menace to how they’ve styled her in Ebenezer, making her almost seem like a risen corpse leading Scrooge through memories of his past. Wonderfully macabre.
Despite what the commercials say, this isn’t exactly a “fresh take” on the story. It’s fairly faithful to the source material, while expanding Scrooge’s backstory, giving a bit more life to Ebenezer’s past romance with Belle (Ellie Bamber), and including later Belle in Ebenezer’s redemption. But beyond that, there’s nothing that really reinvents the wheel. I’m a huge fan of A Christmas Carol and its many adaptations, and while I don’t think Ebenezer will be listed among the classic versions, it’s certainly watchable thanks to Ti West’s visual style and the cast. If you’re looking for an early holiday film to enjoy with the family, you could probably do worse than Ebenezer.

The official ScreenAge Newsletter has arrived! Subscribe to receive a semi-regular round-up of all our exclusive content, including reviews, editorials, Top 100 lists, and more! C'mon, we know you want to venture further into the Wasteland with us!
