
Though I grew up in a different time and place from 1980s New York, James Gray does a lot to acquaint his audience with the universal familiarities of family to settle us in, with things like a father waking his son up early with yard work outside his window, kids doing homework at the kitchen table, and a clinging desire for more than what you have. For the Pearl family, along with so many others, there always seems to be an appetite for something better.
Attempting to steer this family at the helm is Irwin (Miles Teller), an engineer with years of experience, but maybe not to the prestige he’d once hoped. His wife, Hester (Scarlett Johansson), keeps their boys in line while yearning for a home outside the danger and bustle of the city. With the arrival of Irwin’s persuasive and charming older brother, Gary (Adam Driver), and a lucrative new business opportunity, the stage is set for the American dream tragedy of Paper Tiger.
While Gray and fans of his work will be no strangers to the dim and murky New York streets he often favors, Gray mainly uses a feeling of shared family history and a community with a retention of the past as a way to immerse us in this world. Irwin and Gary aren’t just people in this setting; they are a part of this neighborhood that knows them, for better or worse. There’s a sense that this was a place Irwin and Gary once thought they knew well, but as things changed, they began to see it was never the way they saw it in the first place. So, when Gary presents Irwin with a plan to consult with Russian workers on a pollution control project for the Gowanus Canal, it seems like the perfect opportunity to gain financial footing, earn family respect for his profession, and do something worthwhile for his own community.
Paper Tiger relishes in its opening twenty to thirty minutes of suburban bliss before plunging us into an anxious hunt. Gray makes this switch very effectively, as once it starts, you almost beg for those easier days back. Irwin’s easily bruised ego pushes him to show his sons his new enterprise as he ventures out with them late one night for an impromptu inspection. As unfortunately anticipated through our perception of Irwin’s optimistic ambition, he finds he’s suddenly interfered with the Russian mafia. This is when Gray turns up the stress factor, with Irwin and his sons now threatened and sought out by this criminal outfit. What once appeared as a breeze of a business deal has deepened into a pool of paranoia, lies, and danger.

It’s this family unravelling that shows what these characters are capable and not capable of. While Irwin flails out on the outskirts of this operation, Gary starts to get his hands dirty on the inside in an effort to protect his family, along with himself. His connections and cop background get him far, but he begins to see his circle is closing fast. This becomes cleverly visualized through Joaquín Baca-Asay’s sharp cinematography, as his use of shadows deepens the further we get into this pit. It lends for some wonderfully beautiful use of lighting in shots, but also keeps you on edge with its enigmatic darkness.
Paper Tiger is more than just a mob flick; it’s a harsh examination of the men who wanted to take that risky step to make everything better for their families and turned it to ruin. Good, innocent men who think they can take their turn in beating the system until the keepers of the unwritten rules come to bite them. We all wish for more and can see the greener grass on the other side of that fence, but what’s it all worth?
As Paper Tiger closes, you think back to the days of the family by the pool or laughing together on a weekend morning and you strive for the simplicity of things. This situation James Gray presents to us certainly makes us wonder what we would do ourselves, but also when this all might’ve gone wrong without Irwin’s interjection. Sometimes, no matter the intention, the world is rigged against you. It’s a story buried in a cornfield, maybe one of hundreds from a certain time and place, but a far too familiar story for most. So, hold onto the good days while you have ‘em. You never know how suddenly they’ll end.

The official ScreenAge Newsletter has arrived! Subscribe to receive a semi-regular round-up of all our exclusive content, including reviews, editorials, Top 100 lists, and more! C'mon, we know you want to venture further into the Wasteland with us!
