“Where life had no value, death had its price.”
The middle child of Sergio Leone’s Dollars Trilogy, For a Few Dollars More follows Clint Eastwood’s iconic bounty hunter and Lee Van Cleef’s steely Colonel as they form an uneasy alliance to hunt down the dastardly El Indio. It’s built around suspense, understated performances, memorable music, and characters whose motives are rarely straightforward. Although many might say it’s eclipsed by The Good, the Bad and the Ugly, it’s a masterpiece in its own right, and helped redefine the Western genre.
History
By the time Sergio Leone began work on For a Few Dollars More, A Fistful of Dollars had already established the commercial potential of the Italian western. This success led to the development of a sequel, again starring Clint Eastwood as the quiet gunslinger. Leone was able to return with an inflated budget, and more importantly, an inflated ambition. Although filmed mainly in Spain, For a Few Dollars More was presented as a story set in the American West. Stripped of its traditional romanticism, the American frontier looked like a very different place to the audience, full of mercenaries, opportunists, and men with no moral code.
Eastwood was joined by Lee Van Cleef, who offered an interesting, and at times humorous, counterpoint to his character. It’s an interesting dynamic, and the film’s success is built on the back of this uneasy relationship. Their alliance is based on mutual benefit, rather than traditional friendship and a shared sense of justice. But both are judged on their actions rather than motivations, making them easy to root for. We also can’t forget the iconic antagonist, Gian Maria Volontè’s El Indio. He was a more psychologically complex villain than the straightforward outlaws found in many westerns, driven by addiction, cruelty, and a traumatic backstory.
Leone once again worked with composer Ennio Morricone. His unconventional score was central to the film’s atmosphere. The recurring pocket watch theme was used as an instrument of suspense, and the iconic theme tune is still well known to this day. Add to this Leone’s use of extreme close-ups and prolonged pauses, and you have a more rounded and immersive experience than its predecessor. These techniques became defining features of the Dollars trilogy, and helped distinguish it from contemporary American westerns.
Importance
The beauty of the Dollars trilogy in general is in how much it achieved within a genre that had already been explored by cinema in a different way. With For a Few Dollars More, rather than simply repeating the formula of its predecessor, Leone refined it. The first film introduced audiences to a more cynical, violent version of the western hero, but the sequel had a stronger structure, with deeper characters and better pacing. All this established the spaghetti western as more than just a cheaper, violent alternative to Hollywood’s westerns. Leone understood that a gunfight did not need to be fast to be exciting. The tension and build-up were equally, if not more, important than the action itself. The dramatic sequences seen here would influence multiple future westerns, as well as plenty of action films outside the genre.
One of the film’s most interesting choices is its depiction of the bounty hunter. In traditional American westerns, heroes were almost always defined by a clear moral code, even if they sometimes operated outside the law. Leone’s characters can’t really be categorised in the same way. Eastwood’s bounty hunter is largely motivated by money, while Van Cleef’s has a deeply personal reason for pursuing El Indio. This helped develop a narrative that was different from the traditional good versus bad.
Legacy
The film was a major commercial success and ensured Leone was recognised as a master of his craft. It also further established Eastwood’s persona as a quiet and self-contained gunslinger.
Even if it has often sat in the shadow of its successor, the Dollars Trilogy might never have been completed if it wasn’t for the acclaim this film received. For a Few Dollars More is a great example of a director refining his methods before hitting the jackpot with a larger budget and resources to give him a chance to make his magnum opus. It still stands as one of the defining westerns of the 1960s, and one of the most influential westerns ever made.
The official ScreenAge Newsletter has arrived! Subscribe to receive a semi-regular round-up of all our exclusive content, including reviews, editorials, Top 100 lists, and more! C'mon, we know you want to venture further into the Wasteland with us!
