Despite their importance to the genre, there are numerous female characters within horror that have fallen between the cracks of the canon. Ones who aren’t enshrined on merch or shouted out in every countdown, but whose performances linger long after the credits roll. They might come from forgotten exploitation flicks, international nightmares, direct-to-video oddities, or cult classics that never quite crossed into the mainstream—but they matter. In this list, you’ll find scream queens who deserved bigger pedestals, final girls who survived hell only to be ignored by history, and the rare female monsters who weren’t defined by seduction or sympathy—but by raw, unsettling power. These characters don’t just react to horror. They shape it. They weaponize fear, grief, sexuality, trauma, and rage, often in ways that are far more complex than their male counterparts are ever allowed to be.
These are the 100 Most Underrated Female Characters of Horror Cinema.
100. Angela Talbott (Marla English) | The She-Creature (1956)
The She-Creature is basically a 1950s B-movie remake of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde, if Hyde was a rubber suit with boobs and an overbite. Dr. Lombardi (Chester Morris) hypnotizes his assistant Angela to prove reincarnation is real. Instead of channeling Cleopatra or Joan of Arc, she goes full Lovecraft, turning into an amphibious she-demon from before time began.
1950s horror had this weird recurring motif: women who step out of line, sexually or intellectually, get punished by science, space, or Satan. Angela doesn’t get punished for wanting anything; she gets punished for existing as a woman in a man’s experiment. She’s hypnotized, exploited, possessed, and ultimately blamed for things she literally didn’t do. She’s the only one who can’t control the monster, and yet everyone treats her like she’s the problem. This is not played like social commentary; this was just the tenor of the times.
But unlike other damsels in distress from similar B movies, Angela isn’t played as merely a victim. She doesn’t run around in high heels screaming “Oh no! A monster!” while holding her face like she’s posing for the poster. No, Angela looks tired of the monster. Not scared, just over it. Her performance is what sells the ridiculous premise, but it’s the design of the creature that makes the movie memorable. The titular She-Creature looks like a Power Rangers villain, and I mean that as a compliment. The film was obviously made for five dollars and a plate of ham sandwiches, which makes the design that much more impressive. The She-Creature isn’t a great movie by any objective standard. It’s slow, talky, and uses more fog than an amateur haunted house. But Angela Talbott? She’s the heart of it. A metaphor for female agency in a decade allergic to the concept.
99. Ethel Janowski (Priscilla Alden) | Criminally Insane (1975) & Criminally Insane 2 (1987)
When we first meet Ethel in Criminally Insane (also known under the much more accurate alternate title Crazy Fat Ethel), she’s being released from a mental institution because her doctors believe she’s “cured.” The minute she’s back home, she finds out her controlling grandmother has put her on a diet, and within five minutes, Grandma’s a corpse and Ethel’s raiding the icebox like it’s the Ark of the Covenant. Seriously, she’s Indy, but instead of arguing that priceless artifacts belong in a museum, anything edible within her immediate vicinity belongs in her stomach. Ethel Janowski is what happens when someone takes the phrase “chewing the scenery” a little too literally because she’ll chew through that, the sets, and anyone dumb enough to get between her and the fridge.
Ethel is not your average slasher villain. She’s not hunting teenagers. She’s not hiding behind a mask. She’s not even that stealthy—she’ll just straight-up stab you mid-sandwich if you so much as look at her pork chops wrong. She’s an absurd villain with an absurd murderous trigger (it’s literally just gluttony), but that absurdity is what makes these movies work. They feel like slashers by way of John Waters, and Priscilla Alden feels like Divine but stripped of her manic energy. Like Divine if she was shot in the neck with a tranq and it’s slowly taking effect throughout the film.
Then, twelve years later, the world was blessed (or cursed) with Criminally Insane 2, a sequel that’s 40% new footage, 60% recycled scenes from the original, and 100% confusion. It’s basically the Texas Chainsaw Massacre 2 of no-budget horror sequels: it knows it can’t outdo the first one, so it leans into absurdity. This time, Ethel’s back in the asylum, where she’s tormented by the staff, her own delusions, and the film’s non-existent budget. The movie is terrible, but once again, Alden delivers a performance better than the film deserves. Here’s to crazy fat Ethel, the most relatable slasher villain ever because honestly, who hasn’t considered stabbing someone over pie?
98. Marianne Peters (Tig Notaro) | Army of the Dead (2021)
Tig Notaro was digitally inserted into Army of the Dead after it was already shot, replacing notorious sex pest Chris D’Elia, and her five-minute cameo ended up being the best thing about the movie. She plays Marianne Peters, the helicopter pilot hired to get Scott Ward’s (Dave Bautista) crew in and out of zombie-infested Las Vegas, and she carries herself like someone who has already accepted that this job is stupid, dangerous, and probably not worth the money—but she’s doing it anyway. What makes Marianne stand out isn’t backstory or plot importance (she barely gets any); it’s attitude. Tig Notaro plays her with bone-dry detachment, delivering lines like she’s mildly annoyed that a casino heist in a zombie quarantine zone is interrupting her afternoon.
While everyone else is sweating, arguing, or trying to sell us on big emotional arcs, Marianne just leans back, deadpans a joke, and reminds us that someone in this movie understands how ridiculous all of this is. Marianne often feels slightly disconnected from the rest of the cast (due to the fact that she was never on set with any of the cast), but that emotional distance actually suits the character. She’s a hired gun—or rather, hired pilot—who doesn’t bond, doesn’t overshare, and doesn’t pretend this is anything more than a job that might get everyone killed. In a movie stuffed with lore dumps, alpha zombies, robot conspiracy hints, and sequel bait, Marianne Peters is refreshingly simple. She flies the chopper, cracks jokes, and refuses to act impressed. If more Snyder films had characters this memorable, maybe they’d be worth watching.
97. Lisa Moya (Faith Domergue) | Cult of the Cobra (1955)
Everyone knows the iconic Universal monster movies, but they made far more than just Dracula, Frankenstein, and Wolfman. Cult of the Cobra is one of their more obscure outings, and while it’s nowhere near as good as their best work, it still has its strengths. Most notably, the performance of Faith Domergue. The film is about a group of American G.I.s who break every rule they were given at a secret Hindu ceremony and are then hunted down by a beautiful woman named Lisa Moya who has the power to transform herself into a cobra. On paper, Lisa is a mysterious Eurasian woman with a murky past and a vague connection to the film’s snake-worshipping cult. In practice, she’s the embodiment of 1950s exoticism anxiety: foreign, beautiful, unreadable, and dangerous. Domergue leans into this without winking. She turns an allegory into a fully fleshed-out, three-dimensional character.
She’s the film’s secret weapon and the only reason anyone should see it. Her refusal to phone in a one-note supernatural femme fatale is admirable. She transforms a bargain-basement horror flick into something just a little more glamorous, a little more dangerous, and a lot more fun. Cult of the Cobra itself is modest creature-feature nonsense, heavy on postwar paranoia and light on actual snakes, but Lisa Moya gives it texture. She represents the era’s fear of the “unknown woman” as much as the “unknown East,” wrapped together in one elegant, unsettling package. Faith Domergue doesn’t need venom or fangs to leave an impression; she just has to stand there and look at you.
96. Miss Poopinplatz (Phyllis Diller) | The Boneyard (1991)
Miss Poopinplatz is the kind of character name that already tells you The Boneyard is a tad goofy—and Phyllis Diller understands the assignment immediately. As the mysterious, cackling head morgue attendant where the bulk of the film takes place, Diller turns up in the film like a malevolent Looney Tunes character who wandered into a direct-to-video horror movie and decided to stay. Poopinplatz is all crooked smiles, bug-eyed stares, and line deliveries that sound like they’re being hurled at the camera. She looks less like a human being and more like a poor imitation of a Madame Tussauds wax figure. A wax figure with mange and a smoker’s laugh. While the rest of the cast plays things relatively straight, Diller goes full cartoon ghoul, chewing every syllable like it might be her last meal. What makes the character memorable is how gleefully out of step she is with everything else in the movie.
The Boneyard itself is already a tonal mess, lurching between police procedural, splatter comedy, and occult nonsense, but Diller’s performance feels like it’s operating on an entirely different frequency. And yet, somehow, it works. Her presence turns the film from “weird low-budget horror” into “weird low-budget horror with a deranged comedic anchor.” There’s also something perversely perfect about casting Phyllis Diller—a comedian synonymous with shrill laughs and exaggerated personas—as a keeper of undead, stitched-together monstrosities. In a movie packed with grotesque creature effects and VHS-era chaos, she’s the most unhinged element of all—and that’s saying something. Oh, and both she and her poodle turn into giant monsters at different points in the film. Because why not.
95. Mitsuko (Reina Triendl) | Tag (2015)
Mitsuko is the calm eye at the center of Tag, a character who has to shoulder the impossible task of grounding one of Sion Sono’s most aggressively unhinged films. Played by Reina Triendl, Mitsuko is a soft-spoken high school student who has to deal with unimaginable horrors from almost frame one. Seriously, the opening five minutes are amongst the craziest in film history. If you thought the beginning of Ghost Ship was insane, you’re not ready for what happens in this movie. And it only gets crazier from there. Unlike the other girls in Tag, who are introduced only to be spectacularly and cruelly erased, Mitsuko survives. That survival is not framed as triumph, but as burden. Triendl plays her with a quiet stiffness, as if Mitsuko is already exhausted by a world that keeps demanding she run, flee, and watch everyone else die in front of her.
She’s not a scream queen; she’s a witness. What makes Mitsuko compelling is how little agency she’s given and how clearly she feels that lack. She’s shuffled from one nightmare scenario to another—school bus massacre, marathon of death, dream wedding—each one a new costume draped over the same existential dread. By the time Tag reveals its metatextual punchline about male spectatorship and disposable female bodies, Mitsuko has become less a character than a conduit. She represents endurance in a system designed to consume her. Reina Triendl’s restrained performance is what keeps the film from collapsing under the weight of its own absurdity. In a movie obsessed with spectacle and annihilation, Mitsuko’s quiet persistence is the most amazing thing about it.
94. Taryn (Jennifer Rubin) | A Nightmare on Elm Street 3: Dream Warriors (1987)
The Nightmare on Elm Street fandom is almost perfectly divided between two camps: those who swear by the original and those who champion Dream Warriors. Supporters of the first film point to its massive influence, the sheer number of instantly iconic moments, Charles Bernstein’s eerie score, and how fully formed Freddy Krueger feels right out of the gate. The third act may wobble a bit, but nearly everything leading up to it is razor-sharp and foundational. Fans of the third film, on the other hand, love it because it expands on ideas the original only hinted at—most importantly, the notion that you can fight back in your dreams. Dream Warriors is the first, and arguably the only entry in the series, where the victims actively weaponize the dream world against Freddy. It’s an undeniably fun and inventive concept, but no matter how strong the premise is, it ultimately lives or dies on the strength of the characters doing the fighting. Thankfully, the titular Dream Warriors are great. Each one has a different power based around their personality, with Taryn being the best.
She’s a strong-willed, defiant casualty, a character who briefly convinces you that this might be the movie where Freddy finally gets what’s coming to him. Played by Jennifer Rubin with razor-edged attitude, Taryn is introduced as the “bad girl” of Westin Hills—leather jacket, switchblade, nicotine-stained glare—but the film quickly reveals that this toughness is armor, not affectation. In the dream world, that armor becomes literal. Taryn transforms into a full-blown punk warrior: mohawk spiked high, chrome knives snapping out of her arms, ready to brawl Freddy Krueger head-on. It’s one of the film’s most iconic fantasy payoffs, not because it’s subtle, but because it feels earned. This is who Taryn wants to be—strong, unafraid, impossible to corner—after a lifetime of being dismissed as damaged goods. Her fight ultimately doesn’t last long, unfortunately, but for a brief, glorious moment, Taryn makes him look scared, and in an Elm Street movie, that’s the closest thing to victory there is.
93. Jan Compton (Virginia Leith) | The Brain That Wouldn’t Die (1962)
The Brain That Wouldn’t Die is a very dumb movie. But it isn’t bad. Parodies of B movies single out schlock like this and The Attack of the 50 Foot Woman as examples of how dumb sci-fi movies were in the 1950s, but there are much worse examples. The Robot vs the Aztec Mummy, The Monster of Piedras Blancas, The Killer Shrews, and the infamous Plan 9 From Outer Space are much, much worse. I think its reputation comes from its premise, because I’m guessing the vast majority of those making fun of it haven’t even seen it. Even those with zero patience for movies with a ridiculous premise have to admit that it has at least one redeeming element, and that’s Virginia Leith as Jan Compton. She is the most tragic horror character in existence. She’s a character who spends the entire film as an animated severed head on a table. If you thought Sarah Jessica Parker’s fate in Mars Attacks! was weird, it was inspired by this.
She’s been reduced to a literal object while still managing to radiate more humanity than everyone around her. Leith’s performance is the only thing giving the film any emotional weight. Trapped on a tray, unable to move, Jan is left with nothing but her voice, her eyes, and her moral clarity. She pleads, reasons, and eventually condemns Dr. Bill Cortner with a cold fury that the film itself barely seems to understand. While he rambles about progress, ambition, and “fixing” her, Jan becomes the film’s conscience, calling out his cruelty and, in the process, adds some unintentional depth to the film. While it’s definitely soft-sold, there’s a real horror film to be made out of the premise of a woman being reduced to an object in need of fixing. He wasn’t 100% interested until she was his ideal partner. A24 could release that right now, and no one would bat an eye.
92. Kyra Zelas (Mari Blanchard) | She Devil (1957)
She Devil pretends to be a cautionary sci-fi melodrama about science going too far, but it’s really an excuse to let Mari Blanchard serve cunt for 90 minutes. She plays Kyra Zelas, a bitter, socially ostracized woman, who is mocked for her looks and dismissed as disposable by the men around her. After a radical experiment “improves” her appearance, Kyra doesn’t become grateful — she becomes focused. This is not a makeover fantasy; it’s revenge played as high camp. Blanchard plays her as someone who has been paying attention all along, carefully filing away humiliations, waiting for the moment she could finally collect. The film’s poster refers to her as a “female monster,” but the film itself does very little to condemn her on a human level, even when it insists on punishing her narratively.
The movie wants her to be a monster born of science, but Blanchard keeps reminding you that society did most of the work already. There’s also something quietly radical about Kyra in the context of 1950s genre cinema. Female villains of the era were often coded as aberrations — too sexual, too ambitious, too angry. Kyra is all three, and She Devil frames that as a problem to be solved. Yet Blanchard’s performance undercuts the moral lesson. Kyra doesn’t feel like a warning; she feels like a reckoning. The film may wag its finger, but Kyra keeps staring right back. Unwavering. Defiant. By the time She Devil reaches its inevitable “you can’t let a woman like this exist” conclusion, Kyra Zelas has already won. Not because she survives (she doesn’t) but because she dominates every scene she’s in.
91. The Gorgon (Prudence Hyman) | The Gorgon (1964)
In a studio era crowded with colorful monsters and theatrical excess, The Gorgon stands apart by treating its creature as a figure of sorrow rather than spectacle. Hammer, like Universal, produced so many horror films that it started feeling like they were throwing darts at a wall. Updating Medusa to be a horror character was inevitable, and while I would’ve preferred a take that was similar to Creature from the Black Lagoon, The Gorgon still works because of Prudence Hyman. This interpretation of the character isn’t a cackling villain or a rampaging creature, but a curse made flesh. When the Gorgon finally appears, she glides rather than stalks, her movements slow and deliberate, like someone who already knows the outcome of every encounter.
The snakes, stiff as they may be, aren’t played for shock so much as symbolism: this is not a being lashing out, but one burdened with a condition that kills whether she wants it to or not. Hyman gives the creature a solemn dignity that most cinematic Gorgons never bother with. What makes this version memorable is restraint. Hammer keeps the Gorgon mostly offscreen, allowing the fear to build through aftermath and implication. When she does arrive, Hyman doesn’t oversell menace. Her stillness is the threat. The victims don’t die because she’s cruel; they die because they look. She is a warning, a mystery, a monster and a victim all rolled into one, and Hyman’s performance embodies all of them.
90. Abby Williams (Carol Speed) | Abby (1974)
Abby might be one of the most important exploitation films ever made. Not because it reinvented the genre the way Sweet Sweetback’s Baadasssss Song did, or pushed boundaries like Blood Feast, or dragged sleaze into the mainstream like Deep Throat, or turned trash into transgressive art like Pink Flamingos. Abby’s real impact happened behind the scenes.
The film is a blaxploitation supernatural horror film about a woman possessed by a sex demon—a very obvious attempt to ride the success of The Exorcist. But director William Girdler succeeded a little too well. Abby made real money. Four million dollars in its first month in 1974, which would be roughly $26 million today. For a low-budget horror film with an all-Black cast, that’s insane.
Warner Bros. noticed—and they were pissed. They sued to have the film pulled from theaters over alleged copyright infringement, which is why Abby has been difficult to see ever since. The implication is hard to ignore: it didn’t just resemble The Exorcist; it competed with it. And it made enough money to be a threat.
What makes the lawsuit even more absurd is how little the films actually share. A woman is possessed. An exorcism is performed. The actors take the material seriously. That’s it. Those are the similarities. But seriousness matters. The Exorcist had Linda Blair. Abby had Carol Speed. Where Blair is a vessel for demonic evil, Speed is a sexually liberated semen demon. She’s far closer to a succubus than anything from Catholic horror. Speed commits fully to the role, selling both the eroticism and the horror, and she’s the reason the film works. The fact that a performance this fearless and a movie this successful buried by a studio lawsuit is one of exploitation cinema’s great crimes. Abby isn’t forgotten because it failed. It’s forgotten because it scared the wrong people.
89. Temptation (Cynthia Bond) | Def by Temptation (1990)
Ernest Dickerson’s camera does most of the heavy lifting in Def by Temptation, bathing Harlem in neon sweat and shadow, but when the actors step in, Kadeem Hardison and Bill Nunn snatch scenes like pros. Still, the film’s true heartbeat is Cynthia Bond’s Temptation. She isn’t just the demon in the room — she’s the gravity that bends everything toward her.
Temptation is a succubus, yes, but the film wisely avoids turning her into a latex-and-fangs spectacle. Her real power comes from poise, certainty, and a ruthless understanding of how men see themselves. She knows she’s desirable, and she doesn’t have to flaunt it. Bond plays her with icy calm: every smile measured, every glance deliberate. She doesn’t chase anyone — she reflects their hunger back at them and lets them walk straight into the trap.
That’s what makes her so unsettling. Temptation doesn’t seduce so much as she invites. She gives men exactly what they think they want and waits for them to ruin themselves. In a story obsessed with temptation, she becomes something more than a villain; she’s a litmus test. What you do in her presence says everything about who you really are.
Wherever she goes (clubs, bedrooms, even places meant for salvation), the air shifts and suddenly even the safest place in the world feels dangerous. In a genre that so often reduces demonic women to disposable sex objects, Temptation is something rarer and more dangerous. She isn’t punished for her sexuality — she wields it. Def by Temptation may call itself a morality tale, but Temptation feels like something sharper: a reckoning, exposing just how thin the line is between confidence and collapse. Cynthia Bond gives her a regal menace that doesn’t fade when the credits roll.
88. Amy (Amanda Fix) | Lowlifes (2024)
Few phrases scare off horror fans faster than “a Tubi original.” The platform may be thriving as a streaming free-for-all, but its in-house movies usually feel like disposable algorithm bait rather than real cinema. For a long time, it seemed like they hadn’t produced a single film worth taking seriously. Then Lowlifes appeared out of nowhere and blew a hole straight through that reputation. The film slipped out quietly, which is fitting, because most viewers avoid Tubi originals on principle. The ones who ignored that reflex were rewarded with one of the sharpest and most surprising horror films of the year. IMDb’s plot description — “the survival instincts of a road-tripping family are put to the test when they have no other choice but to stay the night at a remote homestead” — is not only accurate, it’s ideal. That’s all you should know going in. Lowlifes thrives on misdirection and sudden shifts in power, and the less you know, the harder it hits.
At the center of all that instability is Amanda Fix as Amy, the film’s emotional and moral anchor. In a story packed with twists, she gives the chaos something human to cling to. Fix plays Amy with a tense, watchful intelligence — the kind of performance that makes you believe she’s clocking danger long before anyone else in the room. She doesn’t need grand speeches or hysterics; her fear, suspicion, and resilience live in her eyes and in the way she carries herself. As the film’s world grows more hostile, Amy becomes the one character you instinctively want to survive.
Lowlifes is a roller coaster of reversals, with more twists than a Chubby Checker concert, and every one of them works best if you walk in blind. But even as the film keeps reinventing itself, Amy remains its steady pulse, grounding the mayhem in something real and vulnerable. Against all odds, Tubi finally did it. Lowlifes isn’t just a good Tubi original — it’s a genuinely great horror film, and Amanda Fix’s Amy is a huge part of why it sticks with you long after the screen goes dark.
87. Harper (Jessie Buckley) | Men (2022)
Harper is one of those horror protagonists who doesn’t get the luxury of being “relatable” so much as enduring. She arrives in the English countryside seeking peace after a trauma the film smartly refuses to soften or excuse. I mean, it’s an A24 film. Trauma porn disguised as horror is their bread and butter, but Men deals with it better than most. And way crazier. From the jump, Buckley plays Harper as guarded but not fragile. Someone trying to reassert control over her own narrative in a world that keeps insisting on rewriting it for her. What makes Harper so compelling is how much of the film’s unease is filtered directly through her perspective. As the film progresses, she becomes increasingly exhausted by the casual menace around her.
Every interaction—especially with Rory Kinnear’s rotating gallery of deeply unsettling men—feels like a test of patience she did not sign up for. Buckley’s performance sells the idea that the real horror isn’t just what these men do, but how normalized their behavior is, how often Harper is expected to accommodate, forgive, or explain herself. By the time Men descends into its infamous final act, Harper has become less a traditional character and more a psychological anchor. The film goes off the rails to such a degree that a lesser actress would’ve been lost amidst the insanity. Whether you find Men profound or maddening, Jessie Buckley ensures Harper is neither a metaphor with legs nor a victim waiting for rescue.
86. Ellie (Alyssa Sutherland) | Evil Dead Rise (2023)
When The Evil Dead hit in 1981, it wasn’t just a horror movie—it was a dare. Sam Raimi, Bruce Campbell, and a handful of friends turned splattery, low-budget desperation into a new kind of kinetic terror. Audiences had never seen anything like it before. Not wanting to repeat himself, Raimi made the sequel an over-the-top comedy that mixes Looney Tunes and Grand Guignol into something cartoonishly baroque. And again, audiences had never seen anything like it before. Army of Darkness pushed that fusion even further, basically turning Ash into a pulp-fantasy hero. Horror takes a backseat to swashbuckling comedy, but the DNA is still there—Deadites, grotesque transformations, and that same manic camera style. It’s less scary, but it codifies Ash as a pop-culture icon. The 2013 Evil Dead reboot swung the pendulum back hard. Gone is the slapstick, and in its place is endurance-test brutality.
Fede Álvarez reframed the Necronomicon as a trauma engine, using addiction, self-harm, and bodily destruction as horror. It was a refreshing take on a franchise known for taking big swings. Then Evil Dead Rise took the series somewhere even bolder: the apocalypse inside a family. By setting the Deadites loose in a cramped apartment building, the franchise re-centered itself on domestic horror (mothers, sisters, children) using possession as a metaphor for generational damage and emotional rot. The change of setting not only opened the door for more gags and a more claustrophobic feel but also higher stakes. Instead of watching a group of friends deal with the horrors of the necronomicon, this was a family caught in the middle of an unthinkable nightmare.
Having to chop up your possessed buddy with an axe would psychologically ruin anyone, but having to kill your own mother who’s trying to feast on your soul? They don’t have words strong enough to convey that level of awful. Ellie, the undead, murderous mother at the center of things, is one of the most vicious gifts the Evil Dead franchise has ever bestowed upon audiences. She isn’t content with gore alone—she wants to humiliate, provoke, and emotionally dismantle. The way she speaks to her children, especially, is pure franchise nastiness, tapping into guilt, resentment, and fear with unnerving precision. By the end of Evil Dead Rise, Ellie has earned her place in the franchise’s hall of infamy. She’s not just scary—she’s mean. Alyssa Sutherland delivers a performance that understands the core of Evil Dead: excess, cruelty, and dark humor fused into something unforgettable. Ellie isn’t a tragic figure you mourn; she’s a nightmare you survive.
85. Darcy Odello (Carolyn Bracken) | Oddity (2024)
In any other movie, Darcy Odello would be the villain. She’s a blind psychic/witch who deals with haunted relics and artifacts, one of which is a grotesque wooden mannequin that acts like a murderous golem. Those are all strong ingredients for a Baba Yaga-flavored cocktail, but she’s actually the protagonist.
A year after her twin sister’s brutal murder, Darcy returns to the house where it happened not to mourn, but to probe. She’s convinced her sister’s husband is somehow connected, and she’s going to prove it. And then she’s going to get retribution. She’s a rare film protagonist who’s ahead of the audience. We assume she’s there to get answers, but she arrives already carrying them. Grief has hardened into purpose, and the residents of that house are about to be confronted by someone who isn’t interested in comfort or closure.
Darcy’s blindness is crucial, not as a limitation but as a recalibration of how horror works around her. She experiences the world through touch and intuition, reading objects the way others read faces. It gives her the second sight, but it also makes her incredibly vulnerable. She’s not stumbling around like Velma, but she can get lost or tricked. She sometimes fails, but she never once feels like a helpless damsel or incompetent in any way. Part of that is attitude, and part of that is her legit witchy powers. What separates Darcy from typical supernatural truth-tellers is her refusal to explain herself. She doesn’t beg anyone to believe her or soften her warnings. Instead, she demonstrates. The grotesque wooden mannequin she brings into the house isn’t just an eerie prop—it’s a declaration of intent. She’s a fascinating character that contains so many layers and is a refreshing subversion of expectations.
84. Anna (Pollyanna McIntosh) | The Woman (2011)
Based on Jack Ketchum’s novel, The Woman hits with the same merciless intensity that defines his work—an unbroken descent into cruelty, brutality, and human depravity. His most well known work is The Girl Next Door and if you’ve ever read it or seen the movies based on it, you know the man isn’t afraid to throw the reader or viewer into hell. He makes torture porn with a purpose. There’s always a point to the extreme violence, and The Woman is no different. The film follows Anna (Pollyanna McIntosh), a cannibalistic woman captured and chained in a suburban basement. In any other movie, she’d be the monster, but Ketchum turns her into a mirror held up to the family’s hypocrisy, misogyny, and violence. The so-called civilized patriarch needs her broken to feel powerful, and Anna’s continued resistance turns his authority into a pathetic, snarling tantrum.
She is one of the most confrontational figures modern horror has ever dared to center. She isn’t designed to be liked, understood, or redeemed—she exists to offend, to unsettle, and to expose the rot hiding behind the thinnest veneer of civilization. From the moment she’s dragged into the film, Anna is framed as “other,” but the real horror quickly reveals itself to be the people insisting on naming her that way. She snarls, bites, laughs at the wrong moments, and refuses every attempt at domestication with animal fury. But she isn’t mindless—she’s defiant. Every scream, every glare, every refusal to comply feels like a rejection of the rules imposed on her by men who believe cruelty equals order. Anna is a force of nature—ugly, righteous, and impossible to contain. She isn’t a symbol of savagery so much as a reminder that when society calls a woman “inhuman,” it’s usually confessing its own sins.
83. Beth Slocum (Aubrey Plaza) | Life After Beth (2014)
Life After Beth is a grade A pun, but I feel like this movie would’ve been more successful if it was called Manic Pixie Dead Girl. Beth Slocum, as played by Aubrey Plaza, is what happens when that archetype dies and comes back with an attitude. Introduced as the perfect, prematurely mourned girlfriend, Beth’s sudden resurrection should be a miracle. Instead, it’s a slow, awkward, emotionally sticky horror comedy about denial, entitlement, and the very specific nightmare of refusing to let a relationship die when it clearly needs to. When she comes back to life, she’s almost normal—slightly off, a little slower, prone to staring too long and saying the wrong thing. But as Beth deteriorates, Plaza leans into the physicality: stiff movements, blank pauses, sudden emotional spikes. The comedy comes from how long everyone pretends this is fine.
Beth isn’t just undead; she’s emotionally regressing, peeling back the politeness to reveal the resentment and boredom that existed long before she died. What makes Beth such a sharp creation is how the film uses her zombification as a metaphor. She becomes increasingly selfish, demanding, and volatile, and the movie refuses to frame this as tragic or romantic. Beth isn’t “back” because love conquered death—she’s back because the people around her can’t let go. Plaza weaponizes Beth’s bluntness, turning every scene into a confrontation with the lie that the relationship was ever perfect. By the end of Life After Beth, Beth Slocum isn’t a monster to be cured or a love to be saved. She’s a decaying truth dragging everyone into the open. She’s a walking reminder that sometimes the worst thing you can do is resurrect something that already told you it was finished.
82. Verónica (Sandra Escacena) | Verónica (2017)
Despite pop culture’s obsession with them, Ouija boards are rarely the true engine of horror on screen. Outside of the Witchboard franchise and the Ouija films, very few movies have managed to turn the novelty “game” into something genuinely terrifying. That’s what makes Verónica stand out—it may be the scariest film ever to center on a piece of party-store mysticism. Loosely inspired by the infamous 1991 case of Estefanía Gutiérrez Lázaro, who died under mysterious circumstances after taking part in a séance, the film follows Verónica (Sandra Escacena), who, along with her friends, conducts a séance with a Ouija board in their school’s basement on a lunar eclipse. What begins as a reckless thrill quickly opens the door to something far more dangerous, setting off a chain of events that will unravel Verónica’s life in terrifying ways.
The horror doesn’t erupt all at once; it leaks into her life in small, invasive ways. Verónica becomes exhausted, irritable, increasingly isolated, and the possession reads less like a sudden takeover and more like something feeding on grief, responsibility, and adolescent confusion. The film understands that terror hits harder when no safe adult is waiting in the wings. By the time Verónica reaches its devastating conclusion, the film has quietly reframed its horror. This isn’t a story about curiosity punished or faith tested—it’s about a girl crushed between responsibility and abandonment. Verónica is just a girl trying to protect her friends and siblings from a force she doesn’t understand. It could be seen as a metaphor for her going through puberty if it wasn’t for the ending. This is not an example of the genre turning childhood experiences into horror; this is true, unexplained nightmare fuel based in reality.
81. Edwina Lionheart (Diana Rigg) | Theatre of Blood (1973)
Theatre of Blood has such a great premise that I’m shocked it hasn’t been remade twice by now. Edward Lionheart (Vincent Price), a once-celebrated Shakespearean actor, is publicly humiliated when a circle of smug London critics denies him a prestigious award. Broken and disgraced, he fakes his own suicide, disappears into the city’s forgotten corners, and returns in disguise to murder each critic using a method inspired by one of Shakespeare’s plays. Each killing is a grotesque performance — Titus Andronicus, The Merchant of Venice, Cymbeline — but with a devilish twist. At his side is a hip-ass cat with a curly afro and a thick handlebar mustache. It’s later revealed that this mysterious helper is none other than Edwina, Edward’s devoted daughter.
Played by Diana Rigg, Edwina might be the most fun she’s ever had on screen. While she doesn’t speak while in disguise, you can tell she’s having a blast under all that makeup. When you act opposite a ham like Vincent Price, there’s no such thing as “over the top.” He’s going to chew scenery, so you either grab a fork and knife and join in or risk getting eaten yourself. And Rigg, who isn’t known for horror, let alone going silly, jumps in with both feet and embraces the wacky tone. Together, she and Price turn humiliation into legend, criticism into carnage. Rigg makes Edwina both heartbreakingly loyal and terrifyingly committed — a daughter who decided that if the world wouldn’t applaud her father, it would at least scream his name forever.
80-61
Who do you think are some of the most underrated female characters in horror movies? Maybe they will show up later on this list!
The official ScreenAge Newsletter has arrived! Subscribe to receive a semi-regular round-up of all our exclusive content, including reviews, editorials, Top 100 lists, and more! C'mon, we know you want to venture further into the Wasteland with us!
