Despite their importance to the genre, there are numerous female characters within horror that have fallen between the cracks of the canon. Ones who aren’t enshrined on merch or shouted out in every countdown, but whose performances linger long after the credits roll. They might come from forgotten exploitation flicks, international nightmares, direct-to-video oddities, or cult classics that never quite crossed into the mainstream—but they matter. In this list, you’ll find scream queens who deserved bigger pedestals, final girls who survived hell only to be ignored by history, and the rare female monsters who weren’t defined by seduction or sympathy—but by raw, unsettling power. These characters don’t just react to horror. They shape it. They weaponize fear, grief, sexuality, trauma, and rage, often in ways that are far more complex than their male counterparts are ever allowed to be.
These are the 100 Most Underrated Female Characters of Horror Cinema.
40. Alucarda (Tina Romero) | Alucarda (1977)
Alucarda, directed by cult madman Juan López Moctezuma, opens at a convent that looks like it was decorated by Satan’s goth cousin. Enter the titular Alucarda, an orphan with a tragic past and a “don’t tell me what to do” aura. She instantly bonds with the sweet, sheltered Justine (Susana Kamini)—and by “bonds,” I mean drags her into the woods for a forbidden blood oath. From there, the plot goes off the rails in the most fabulous way possible. Alucarda’s wild energy awakens something dark inside both girls. The nuns decide the only solution is extreme exorcism. Cue a whole lotta chanting and screaming. The convent becomes a battleground between religious authority and raw, unhinged female rebellion.
Alucarda feels like a gothic rock star trapped in a nun movie. She’s intense, defiant, and emotionally feral. She’s like if your dramatic friend discovered Satan and made it her entire personality. Alucarda isn’t just possessed by demons; she’s possessed by freedom, by rage, by the need to be seen. The film works because it mixes horror with melodrama. It’s tragic, it’s camp, it’s emotionally loud. But beneath the chaos, it’s a story about repression, forbidden desire, and what happens when young women are told their feelings are sinful. Alucarda is not a villain, but a girl who refuses to be told what to do.
39. Lucía (Ester Expósito) | Venus (2022)
We meet Lucía working as a dancer in a sweaty, neon-soaked Madrid club. After a deal goes violently wrong, she grabs a mysterious bag of drugs and runs for her life. Stabbed, bleeding, and being hunted by men who absolutely want their merchandise back, she has one option: disappear. So she hides out at her sister Rocío’s apartment in a decaying high-rise called the Venus building.
The problem? The building itself might be more of a threat than the murderous drug dealers after her. Something about the neighbors feels off. They stare too long, whisper things that feel ominous, and generally give off bad vibes. When Rocío suddenly vanishes, Lucía is left alone with her young niece Alba and the creeping realization that the apartment isn’t just cursed, but feeding on fear.
Lucía is no saint. She’s reckless, sarcastic, and emotionally guarded. But when the supernatural horror begins closing in, she transforms. What starts as a desperate escape from criminals becomes a full-blown battle against something ancient and evil lurking beneath the floors. She doesn’t get holy water or priestly help—just grit, rage, and the instinct to protect a child who deserves a future.
What makes Lucía iconic is that she never becomes quiet or passive. She fights with attitude, panic, and raw survival energy. She screams, she runs, she refuses to lie down and die. She is messy. She is brave. She is exhausted—and she still keeps going.
In Venus, Lucía is a glam disaster turned horror heroine: a woman thrown into the abyss who flips it off on the way down. She may be bleeding, hunted, and cursed, but she is not powerless. She is proof that even in a building named after a goddess, the real divine power is pure, furious will.
38. Dr. Rose Casper (Marin Ireland) and Celie Morales (Judy Reyes) | Birth/Rebirth (2023)
Dr. Rose Casper is a brilliant embryologist with the emotional warmth of a lukewarm cup of decaf and a moral compass that wobbles like a poorly made chair. Like all mad scientists, she is obsessed with pushing the boundaries of science, which means doing terribly unethical things in the pursuit of her goal, such as, if you couldn’t guess based on the title, reanimating the dead. The Igor to her Frankenstein is Celie Morales (Judy Reyes), a heart surgeon who is competent, grounded, and the exact voice of reason that Rose willfully ignores. Watching their personalities clash is what makes the film work as well as it does.
Rose will have an insane idea, and watching Celie initially push back but then ultimately go along with it is like watching a sane person at a circus full of chainsaws — equal parts worried and riveted. Birth/Rebirth is a roller coaster of philosophical questions, existential dread, and beautifully gross body horror.
Is it a celebration of scientific progress? An indictment of it? A giant metaphor for motherhood, loss, and identity? Yes, yes, and yes. It’s also a showcase for two incredible actresses to flex their talents and undeniable chemistry. Ireland and Reyes carry Birth/Rebirth from intriguing concept to cinematic experience that will leave you thinking and squirming in equal measure.
37. Eva Galli / Alma Mobley (Alice Krige) | Ghost Story (1981)
Imagine the kind of woman whose smile is so mesmerizing it drives every man around them insane. That’s Eva Galli. She’s stunning, perplexing, and impossible to ignore. Alice Krige embodies Eva with a hypnotic, otherworldly, and unknowable gaze. Her stare suggests she knows all your darkest secrets but doesn’t care.
Krige also portrays Alma Mobley, who has the same icy charm as Eva, but with a slightly different flavor. It’s like comparing two equally gorgeous but suspiciously sentient Renaissance paintings. This dual identity isn’t a plot twist so much as it is karma manifest. Ghost Story involves four elderly gentlemen who served together in an unnamed war and now gather regularly to complain about creaky joints and haunted memories.
They swap ghost stories like they do arthritis medicine and anti-inflammatory cream, but the scariest story isn’t one they invented or heard told years earlier; it’s one from their past that’s now back for revenge. That’s how Eva/Alma factor into the story. The dual identity is the entire lynchpin of the film. Eva = beautiful mystery. Alma = eternal consequence. One was wronged, and the other is back to torment them, but they’re both the same character.
Krige dominates the movie with very little screen time and even less dialogue. Eva/Alma is part loveliness, part emotional reckoning, all terrifying. It’s one of the many roles that should’ve turned Krige into a genre superstar, but for whatever reason, it never happened.
36. Carmilla (Annette Stroyberg) | Blood and Roses (1960)
You’d think a hot lesbian vampire countess that targets hot female virgins would be more famous, but you’d be wrong. That premise alone should have at least fifty soft core movies attached to it and yet, almost nothing. Leave it to the European art house to finally get the ball rolling. Blood and Roses centers on Leopold (Mel Ferrer), who’s engaged to the delicate and dreamy Georgia (Elsa Martinelli). They’re at his family’s ancient castle planning a masked ball when his old childhood friend Carmilla shows up, who shares more than a passing resemblance to Millarca Karnstein, the original owner of the estate who passed more than 500 years ago. Millarca was in love with her cousin Ludwig but died before they could be married. Ludwig vowed fidelity but went on to get engaged to three other women, all of whom died right before their wedding day. We later find out that the Karnsteins were all vampires who were all killed off. We also learn that Leopold is the spitting image of Ludwig and that Millarca may want to rekindle their centuries-old romance, by any means necessary. Cue possession and tons of murder.
The film is a loose adaptation of Sheridan Le Fanu’s novel that plays fast and loose with the source material, but what it gets right is the Gothic atmosphere and the main performance. Annette Vadim (credited as Annette Stroyberg) brings a wonderfully melancholy quality to Carmilla that makes her transformation feel less like a simple descent into vampirism and more like someone being swallowed up by an obsession she barely understands. Her performance is easily one of the film’s greatest strengths, and it’s a shame she isn’t discussed more often alongside the actresses who became synonymous with European vampire cinema. For a movie that rarely gets mentioned outside of hardcore vampire-horror circles, Blood and Roses is remarkably memorable, and Annette Vadim’s performance deserves far more attention than it usually receives.
35. Sarah Shagal (Sharon Tate) | The Fearless Vampire Killers (1967)
The Fearless Vampire Killers is not a good movie. Roman Polanski is many things (ahem), but funny isn’t one of them. It does, however, have one thing that makes it worth watching, and that’s the performance of Sharon Tate as Sarah Shagal. She not only gets the tone and enjoys playing with the absurdity of the premise, but is magnetically beautiful in it. Every time she’s on screen, it’s impossible to look at anything else. She was cast to be a plot point — the helpless target of the sinister Count von Krolock (Iain Quarrier) — but she delivers so much more than just terrified eye candy.
What makes Sarah such a standout character is the warmth and innocence Tate brings to her, giving the movie an emotional center beneath all of its macabre humor and gothic absurdity. She isn’t simply there to be the damsel in distress; Tate gives Sarah a real presence.
Watching The Fearless Vampire Killers now, knowing how tragically her life and career were cut short, adds an unavoidable sadness to what should otherwise be a playful and beautiful piece of gothic horror. Sharon Tate’s passing was an enormous loss to cinema, because performances like this make you wonder just how much more she could have accomplished. Sarah Shagal remains one of her most charming roles, and The Fearless Vampire Killers is a perfect reminder of the talent that was taken from audiences far too soon.
34. Mora (Linda Lawson) | Night Tide (1961)
Curtis Harrington’s underseen film follows Johnny Drake (Dennis Hopper), a sailor who becomes fascinated by Mora after meeting her at a seaside carnival, where she performs as a mermaid. There’s more to Mora than the act, though. She believes she may actually be a siren, cursed to draw men toward their deaths, and the mysterious history surrounding her only makes Johnny more determined to understand her. In any other movie, Mora would be portrayed as some obvious supernatural temptress that’s clearly trying to ensnare Johnny in a trap, but Night Tide isn’t like any other movie. She’s sad, isolated, and visibly troubled by the possibility that there might be something monstrous inside her. That makes her much more interesting than the usual femme fatale, because Mora doesn’t seem to enjoy the power she supposedly possesses—she’s terrified of it.
Linda Lawson is fantastic, giving the character this wonderfully eerie combination of innocence and melancholy. She can look like she stepped straight out of a fever dream one moment and then seem painfully vulnerable the next. The film eventually provides a more human explanation for Mora’s supposed curse, but Harrington never completely destroys the feeling that there might be something genuinely supernatural lurking beneath the surface. That uncertainty is a huge part of the movie’s charm. Mora feels less like a conventional horror villain and more like a tragic figure caught between the real world and some strange nightmare of her own making, and Lawson’s performance is what makes her unforgettable.
33. Clare Carroll (Aisling Franciosi) | The Nightingale (2018)
Labeling The Nightingale a horror is a generous description of the genre. It’s never scary, nor is it ever trying to be. It’s not even suspenseful or tense, let alone dread-inducing. It has almost nothing in common with your typical horror film and would be more accurately classified as a psychological drama, so its inclusion on this list is a bit of a cheat. However, I think a case could be made that the main character goes through just as much (and in some cases, way more) as any final girl, and the world she inhabits is far more brutal and ugly. The film may not be horror, but her entire existence is one.
Set in 1825 Tasmania, the film follows Clare Carroll (Aisling Franciosi), an Irish convict who has been subjected to years of abuse and exploitation by the British military authorities. After a devastating act of violence destroys what little life she has managed to build, Clare sets out after the men responsible, joining forces with Billy, an Aboriginal tracker played by Baykali Ganambarr.
What begins as a revenge story gradually becomes something much more complicated, as Clare and Billy are forced to confront the cruelty of the colonial world around them while reluctantly developing a bond built on shared trauma and survival. Clare could have easily been written as a simple revenge heroine, but Franciosi gives her so much more than that. She’s furious, frightened, grieving, and determined, and those emotions are allowed to exist alongside one another rather than turning her into an unstoppable action hero. There’s a rawness to Franciosi’s performance that makes Clare incredibly difficult to forget; even when she’s consumed by anger, you can still see the exhausted woman underneath it all.
The Nightingale is an extremely difficult film to watch, but Clare gives it its emotional center. Her journey isn’t about becoming some hardened killing machine. Instead, it’s about what happens when a person who has been denied any real control over her own life finally decides that she will determine what happens next.
32. Diane LeFanu (Celeste Yarnall) | The Velvet Vampire (1971)
Diane LeFanu is the sort of vampire who could invite you into her home, pour you a drink, and have you completely under her spell before you even realize you’re in danger. In The Velvet Vampire, a married couple, played by Michael Blodgett and Sherry Miles, accept an invitation from the mysterious Diane to visit her remote desert estate, only to discover that their glamorous hostess has considerably more on her mind than playing tour guide. As the weekend unfolds, Diane toys with the couple through seduction, dreams and psychological manipulation, while the truth about her vampiric nature gradually comes to light.
Celeste Yarnall is terrific as Diane, giving her an almost dreamlike quality that makes it difficult to tell where the sensuality ends and the menace begins. She isn’t played as some snarling creature of the night, but as cool, confident, and completely in command, which is what makes her frightening. There is a wonderfully strange, almost hypnotic quality to Diane, as though she wandered in from some decadent nightmare and simply decided to make the desert her kingdom. Yarnall understands that the less she gives away, the more fascinating Diane becomes. Her performance is a huge part of what makes The Velvet Vampire such an unusual entry in 1970s vampire cinema, and Diane LeFanu is the reason the whole bizarre fever dream works.
31. Yella Fichte (Nina Hoss) | Yella (2007)
The most underrated actor/director pairing working today has to be Nina Hoss and Christian Petzold. They’ve made six films together, with Phoenix being their most famous. That film put them on the map and rightfully so. It’s a modern masterpiece, but I’d argue they should’ve already been on everyone’s radars seven years earlier for their film Yella.
Yella is a chilly, quietly unnerving psychological thriller that begins as a story of escape before gradually revealing something far more unsettling beneath its surface. After leaving her failed marriage and hometown behind, Yella (Hoss) enters the corporate world, where new opportunities and a mysterious businessman offer her the chance to start over. But the past turns out to be a ghost that refuses to stop haunting her. Strange noises, unsettling visions, and fragments of memory begin creeping into her new existence, gradually transforming what starts as a cold, quietly observed drama into something much more disturbing.
Hoss is absolutely mesmerizing in the title role because she understands that Yella doesn’t need to constantly tell us what she’s feeling. Her face becomes its own mystery, with every blank stare and moment of hesitation suggesting that there is something underneath the surface she either can’t or won’t confront. Yella is ambitious, frightened, lonely, and increasingly desperate to hold onto the freedom she’s been chasing, and Hoss makes all of those contradictions feel completely natural. She never feels like a conventional horror protagonist; she’s simply a woman trying to build herself a better life, which makes the film’s gradual descent into psychological nightmare all the more effective. Yella is the kind of movie that sneaks up on you, and Hoss gives it a lead performance that is so controlled and quietly unsettling that by the time the pieces start falling into place, you’re already completely trapped inside Yella’s strange little nightmare.
30. Deborah Tennis (Natasha Lyonne) | All About Evil (2010)
All About Evil is the kind of campy, blood-soaked horror comedy made for a midnight screening, even if the cult it deserves has yet to fully embrace it. The film follows Deborah Tennis, a meek librarian who inherits her father’s failing movie theater and ironically finds that the key to keeping it alive is killing people, filming it, and screening the murders. From there, she starts turning genuine violence into increasingly elaborate horror movies, surrounding herself with a bizarre little troupe of accomplices and transforming the dying theater into her personal slaughterhouse and studio. Lyonne is fantastic as Deborah, playing her initially as this painfully awkward, socially stunted woman who seems more comfortable around old horror movies than actual people, before gradually revealing the enormous ego and rage bubbling underneath.
She desperately wants to be loved, respected, and recognized as an artist, and when conventional filmmaking doesn’t give her that validation, she simply decides to make her movies more authentic. Deborah is funny, pathetic, frightening, and completely unhinged, often all within the same scene. What makes her such a great horror character is that her obsession with cinema isn’t just a gimmick; it’s the language through which she understands the world. She doesn’t just want to make a great horror movie—she wants to become the star of her own twisted little nightmare, and Natasha Lyonne makes every step of that descent wonderfully deranged.
29. Elizabeth Warren / The Monster (Vivian Lanko) | Rejuvenatrix (1988)
Most of Batman’s rogues are horror characters if you remove the Dark Knight from the equation. There’s a man-sized bat, a mutated crocodile, and even a bona fide zombie. He has more monsters than any other superhero, so turning Clayface into a body horror film makes all the sense in the world, especially since his story has basically been told already in the woefully underseen Rejuvenatrix.
The film follows aging actress Ruth Warren, who becomes obsessed with restoring her youth and agrees to undergo an experimental treatment developed by Dr. Gregory Ashton. The treatment works, transforming her into the beautiful young Elizabeth, but there’s a pretty major catch: the serum doesn’t last, and keeping herself young requires something far more horrifying than another trip to the beauty salon. As Elizabeth’s body begins to deteriorate, she starts transforming into a grotesque creature and must feed on human brains to maintain her youthful appearance.
It’s wonderfully trashy 1980s horror, but Elizabeth is what really makes it memorable. Like Clayface, she’s essentially a human being trapped inside a body that can no longer reliably maintain its shape, although Elizabeth’s transformations are driven by her desperate obsession with youth rather than revenge or supervillainy. Vivian Lanko has a blast with the role, selling both sides of Elizabeth: the glamorous woman terrified of losing her beauty and the increasingly grotesque creature hiding underneath it. What makes her more than just another movie monster is that the horror is directly connected to what she wants most. Elizabeth isn’t trying to become a monster; she’s trying desperately not to become an old woman, and the cruel joke is that her attempt to preserve her youth turns her into something far more frightening than anything she was afraid of becoming.
28. Lilico (Erika Sawajiri) | Helter Skelter (2012)
Sion Sono has never been a filmmaker particularly interested in behaving himself. His filmography jumps from punk provocations to apocalyptic madness, sleazy exploitation, surreal comedy, and outright cinematic insanity, and Helter Skelter fits comfortably into that wonderfully unhinged catalog. The film follows Lilico, a wildly successful model whose flawless appearance is the result of extensive cosmetic surgery, as her carefully constructed life begins to collapse under the pressure of fame, beauty, and the fear of being replaced. Erika Sawajiri is fantastic as Lilico, giving the character exactly the mixture of arrogance, desperation, cruelty, and vulnerability the role demands.
Sawajiri never reduces her to a simple villain. She can be cruel, narcissistic, manipulative, and absolutely monstrous, but there is always this desperation underneath her behavior. Lilico knows that her entire career—and, in her mind, her entire worth—depends on remaining beautiful, desirable, and famous. Watching that manufactured perfection deteriorate becomes almost like watching the character herself being erased piece by piece. She’s both predator and victim, someone who has completely bought into the idea that beauty is power only to discover how brutally disposable that power can be.
27. Celia Carmichael (Rebecca Smart) | Celia (1989)
Australia has quietly produced some of the strangest and most underrated horror movies ever made. From Patrick and Long Weekend to Razorback, Next of Kin, and Dead-End Drive-In, there’s a wonderfully offbeat streak running through Australian horror that deserves far more attention. Celia fits right into that tradition, turning childhood imagination and suburban unease into something genuinely unsettling.
Set in 1950s Melbourne, the film follows nine-year-old Celia, a lonely girl whose fascination with rabbits, horror stories, and the mysterious disappearance of her father begins to blur the line between fantasy and reality. What makes Celia so memorable is the way it views the world almost entirely through a child’s eyes, where ordinary neighbors can become monsters, and games can take on frightening consequences. It’s strange, melancholy, occasionally nightmarish, and unlike much else in Australian horror. It’s a forgotten little gem that feels more disturbing the longer you sit with it, and a huge part of its power is the central performance from Rebecca Smart.
Celia is never played as some generic creepy child. She’s funny, lonely, imaginative, vindictive, vulnerable, and occasionally downright terrifying. The Hobyahs (the mythological creatures she believes in) are frightening, but Celia’s fascination with them is even more interesting because she uses them to process things she can’t possibly understand: death, cruelty, punishment, political hatred, and the frightening behavior of adults. There’s something wonderfully twisted about watching a child’s fantasy world become a place where she has more power than she does in real life.
26. Ruka (Eihi Shiina) | Tokyo Gore Police (2008)
Somewhere between the samurai, the cop, and the revenge movie heroine sits Ruka, one of the coolest characters to emerge from Japan’s gloriously unhinged wave of extreme cinema. Played by Eihi Shiina, Ruka is the dead-serious center of Tokyo Gore Police, a film that otherwise seems determined to see just how far it can push its own insanity.
In a future Tokyo where the police have become a privatized force and bizarre mutants called Engineers terrorize the population, Ruka hunts them down while investigating the murder of her father. Yoshihiro Nishimura throws practically every imaginable piece of outrageous genre excess at the screen, but Ruka never loses her composure. She carries her sword, goes about her grisly business, and stares down the madness around her with the sort of cold determination that makes her feel like she belongs in a completely different movie.
Shiina, who had already made an enormous impression in Audition, gives Ruka a terrific combination of toughness, sadness, and deadpan intensity. She isn’t merely there to provide an excuse for the next outrageous set piece; her quest for revenge gives the movie an emotional spine beneath all the blood, mutations and deliberately excessive spectacle. Tokyo Gore Police came out of the same wonderfully strange strain of Japanese extreme cinema that produced films such as The Machine Girl, Meatball Machine, RoboGeisha, Vampire Girl vs. Frankenstein Girl, and Helldriver, movies that embraced practical effects, manga-inspired lunacy and an almost competitive level of excess. Ruka, however, is what keeps Tokyo Gore Police from becoming just a collection of increasingly outrageous set pieces. She is the straight-faced warrior at the center of the storm, and Eihi Shiina plays her with just enough humanity to make this completely ridiculous world feel strangely believable.
25. Jennifer (Jennifer Fraser) | Capture Kill Release (2016)
There’s something particularly nasty about Capture Kill Release because it takes the familiar found-footage setup and strips away the supernatural entirely. The film follows Jennifer and Farhang, a young couple who decide to record themselves committing a murder, turning their relationship into a horrifying little experiment in how far two people can go together. Until Farhang decides it’s too much and no longer wants to participate, creating a tension that can only be resolved with blood.
Jennifer Fraser is especially memorable because she never makes Jennifer feel like a one-note psychopath. She can be playful, affectionate, and completely ordinary one moment, before revealing a colder and increasingly disturbing side as her plan moves forward. Jennifer seems to take genuine pleasure in pushing Farhang beyond his limits, and what makes her so unsettling is the way she treats something horrific with the casualness of an everyday activity. This makes Jennifer feel like a real person whose darker impulses have simply been given room to run wild. In a genre packed with bigger, bloodier killers, Jennifer stands out precisely because her most frightening weapon is how normal she can seem.
24. Sister Hyde (Martine Beswick) | Dr. Jekyll and Sister Hyde (1971)
There have been countless versions of Robert Louis Stevenson’s Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde, but Hammer’s Dr. Jekyll and Sister Hyde might be one of the strangest, taking the familiar tale and giving it a gloriously lurid gender-bending makeover. Ralph Bates plays Dr. Henry Jekyll, a Victorian scientist whose attempts to discover a means of prolonging life lead him to a horrifying new serum that transforms him into the seductive and murderous Sister Hyde, played by the wonderful Martine Beswick. What starts as scientific curiosity quickly spirals into murder as Jekyll discovers that maintaining his female alter ego requires increasingly gruesome ingredients.
Beswick is terrific as Hyde, bringing a seductive confidence and icy menace to a character who could easily have been treated as a gimmick. She isn’t simply Jekyll in a dress; Sister Hyde feels like a fully unleashed side of his personality, liberated from the restraints of his respectable public life. Add in the film’s wonderfully sleazy Hammer atmosphere, its twisted use of Victorian history and its willingness to take Stevenson’s story someplace completely bonkers, and you have one of the more memorable—and underrated—Jekyll and Hyde variations.
23. Özge Dogruol (Violetta Schurawlow) | Cold Hell (2017)
Some thriller protagonists spend the entire movie screaming for help while the killer runs circles around them. Özge Dogruol isn’t one of those women. Played by Violetta Schurawlow, Özge is a Turkish immigrant living in Vienna who works as a taxi driver and trains in Muay Thai, giving her a toughness that becomes increasingly important when she finds herself in the middle of a nightmare. After witnessing a woman being brutally murdered from her apartment, Özge becomes the next target of the killer, and when the police refuse to take her seriously, things become even more personal after her cousin is killed by mistake.
From there, Cold Hell turns into a nasty game of cat and mouse as Özge tries to identify the murderer while fighting to stay alive. Schurawlow gives Özge a terrific combination of vulnerability and bottled-up rage, making her feel like a real person rather than some invincible action heroine. She’s scared, she’s furious, and she’s absolutely willing to throw down when pushed. Cold Hell is a gritty little thriller, but Özge is what gives it its bite.
22. Anna Madden (Charlotte Burke) | Paperhouse (1988)
Bernard Rose is probably best known for Candyman. However, before he sent an urban legend stalking the streets of Chicago, he made Paperhouse, a much stranger and deeply unsettling little fantasy.
Charlotte Burke plays Anna Madden, a lonely young girl who discovers that a drawing she makes of a house somehow becomes the gateway to a dream world that she can actually enter. At first, the paper house seems like an escape from the frustrations of her unhappy home life, but Anna soon discovers that she can alter the strange world by changing her drawings—and that her dreams have consequences she can’t simply erase with a pencil.
The imagery is the real star here, with the stark paper landscapes, bizarre transformations, and dream logic giving the film an eerie, almost nightmarish quality. Anna is a fascinating protagonist because Paperhouse never treats her imagination as something completely safe or comforting; her drawings become an extension of her fears, loneliness, and desire to have some control over the world around her. Burke gives the character a wonderfully natural performance, carrying the film through a story where childhood fantasy gradually mutates into something genuinely frightening. It’s a beautiful, creepy, and surprisingly haunting film that proves Rose had a very different kind of nightmare in him long before Candyman.
21. Lucy Harbin (Joan Crawford) | Straight-Jacket (1964)
Joan Crawford with an axe, a cocktail dress, and absolutely nothing left to lose. I mean, Strait-Jacket was practically designed to become a cult classic on that alone. Crawford plays Lucy Harbin, a woman who returns home after spending twenty years in a psychiatric institution following the murder of her husband, hoping to rebuild her life and reconnect with her daughter Carol. For a while, it seems like she might actually get that second chance, but when people around her begin turning up dead, the past starts creeping back into the present and Lucy’s fragile grip on reality comes into question.
Crawford is magnificent here, throwing herself into the role with all the intensity you’d expect, whether Lucy is attempting to appear respectable or completely losing her composure. The film walks a wonderfully trashy line between psychological thriller, murder mystery, and Grand Guignol horror, with William Castle piling on the suspense and giving Crawford plenty of room to chew the scenery.
Lucy Harbin is memorable because she isn’t simply a monster or a victim. Instead, she’s a deeply troubled woman desperately trying to escape the identity everyone has already assigned to her, only to find that the past isn’t finished with her yet.
60-41 | 20-1
Who do you think are some of the most underrated female characters in horror movies who haven’t appeared on this list yet? Maybe they will show up in the Top 20!
The official ScreenAge Newsletter has arrived! Subscribe to receive a semi-regular round-up of all our exclusive content, including reviews, editorials, Top 100 lists, and more! C'mon, we know you want to venture further into the Wasteland with us!
