Despite their importance to the genre, there are numerous female characters within horror that have fallen between the cracks of the canon. Ones who aren’t enshrined on merch or shouted out in every countdown, but whose performances linger long after the credits roll. They might come from forgotten exploitation flicks, international nightmares, direct-to-video oddities, or cult classics that never quite crossed into the mainstream—but they matter. In this list, you’ll find scream queens who deserved bigger pedestals, final girls who survived hell only to be ignored by history, and the rare female monsters who weren’t defined by seduction or sympathy—but by raw, unsettling power. These characters don’t just react to horror. They shape it. They weaponize fear, grief, sexuality, trauma, and rage, often in ways that are far more complex than their male counterparts are ever allowed to be.
These are the 100 Most Underrated Female Characters of Horror Cinema.
60. Cissy (Carol Kane) | The Mafu Cage (1978)
The Mafu Cage is one of those cult films that feels like it escaped from an insane asylum. The title alone sounds dangerous. Then Carol Kane shows up and makes it unforgettable. Ellen (Lee Grant) is a wealthy woman living in a decaying Hollywood mansion while secretly caring for her sister Cissy, who is deeply disturbed and afraid of the outside world. Cissy believes the world is unsafe and clings to Ellen for emotional survival. To protect her—and others—Ellen builds a special room for Cissy called the “Mafu Cage.” It’s meant to keep her from hurting herself or anyone else. But the more Ellen tries to live her own life, the more Cissy becomes controlling and jealous. What begins as caretaking slowly turns into a psychological nightmare. Carol Kane plays Cissy like a broken child trapped in an adult body.
Her voice shifts from soft and pleading to sharp and frightening. She never feels like a stereotype of “madness.” Instead, she feels painfully real. Her movements are nervous and tense. Her eyes are always searching. Every word feels loaded with fear, need, and anger. You can see how desperate she is to keep Ellen close—even if it means destroying her. Cissy isn’t a monster. She’s human, and that’s what makes her unsettling. She doesn’t attack with weapons—she uses guilt, fear, and emotional control. She represents what happens when love becomes possession and when care turns into captivity. Cissy is tragic, frightening, and unforgettable. Kane’s performance is the heart of the film and the reason The Mafu Cage still holds power today.
59. Wanda Reed / Venus (Maria Rohm) | Venus in Furs (1969)
Wanda Reed is not introduced so much as discovered — her naked body washed up on a beach like a cursed art installation. From that moment on, it’s clear that Venus in Furs is less a movie and more a hallucination about desire, jealousy, and revenge. Everything is staged like a dream, and everything operates on nightmare logic.
Jimmy Logan (James Darren), a trumpet player, finds Wanda’s body on the beach. Instead of calling the police like a normal human, he becomes obsessed with her. Soon after, Wanda begins appearing to him — alive, seductive, and always just out of reach. Jimmy is drawn into her world, meeting a group of rich, bored predators who may have been responsible for her death. As he gets closer to the truth, the lines between reality, memory, and fantasy collapse.
Is Wanda alive? Is she a ghost? Is Jimmy losing his mind? Since this is a Jesús Franco film, the answer is yes. She is velvet-covered vengeance that drifts through the film like a beautiful phantasm. Maria Rohm plays Wanda like a living fantasy, even when she may or may not be alive. She is glamorous, distant, untouchable — the kind of woman men project their worst impulses onto and then act shocked when she haunts them. Her voice is calm, her gaze unreadable, her presence hypnotic. She isn’t screaming or pleading — she’s watching. Every man sees something different in her: victim, goddess, lover, object. Wanda uses that. She lets them expose themselves while she stays mysterious, turning their obsession back on them. Venus in Furs isn’t about solving a murder; it’s about being consumed by one. It’s moody, strange, and completely unhinged. And it is held together by the strength of its captivating lead.
58. Nevenka (Daliah Lavi) | The Whip and the Body (1963)
Before The Whip and the Body, Mario Bava had already turned the horror world inside out with Black Sunday, The Girl Who Knew Too Much, and Black Sabbath—films that dripped with shadow, color, and style so thick you could practically wear them as perfume. By 1963, he wasn’t just making horror movies; he was building haunted dream worlds. So, when he gave us The Whip and the Body, a gothic psychodrama so lush, so emotionally unhinged, it felt like a Technicolor nightmare with a heartbeat.
At the center of it all is Nevenka. The plot is a full-blown Victorian soap opera. Nevenka is married to the gentle, noble Kurt Menliff, a man so kind and safe he might as well be wallpaper. Unfortunately for her sanity, her heart belongs to Kurt’s sadistic brother, Christian—aka the castle’s resident leather-clad nightmare.
When Christian returns from exile, Nevenka is instantly pulled back into their twisted past. He humiliates her, threatens her, dominates her… and she cannot stop loving him. It’s toxic romance as gothic opera. Then Christian is murdered—allegedly. But instead of moving on, Nevenka becomes even more consumed. She starts seeing him everywhere: on staircases, in corridors, in mirrors. Is he haunting her? Is she unraveling? Or is this castle just a deluxe showroom for unresolved trauma? Nevenka is a tragic, hypnotic figure—caught between safety and self-destruction, between candlelit respectability and a man who literally carries a whip. This was Fifty Shades of Grey fifty years before it came out. It’s radically ahead of its time in terms of its depictions of BDSM. Being sexually perverse is always a trait of a villain, but here, Nevenka wears it like a crown.
57. Epiphany Proudfoot (Lisa Bonet) | Angel Heart (1987)
Before Angel Heart even hit theaters, it was already infamous—because America was not prepared for wholesome Denise Huxtable to step out of the Cosby living room and straight into the sultry, blood-soaked shadows of a neo-noir horror film. Lisa Bonet’s casting caused absolute moral panic: headlines, clutching pearls, and one very public fallout with The Cosby Show. Suddenly, Bonet wasn’t the “nice girl” anymore—she was cinema’s most dangerous revelation. And honestly? Thank God.
Enter Epiphany Proudfoot: part femme fatale, part voodoo priestess, part gothic fever dream in human form. From the moment she slinks into the film, you know the movie has changed. She isn’t just a character—she’s a warning wrapped in silk and shadow. The plot of Angel Heart is pure sweaty noir nightmare fuel. Mickey Rourke plays a down-on-his-luck private eye hired by a mysterious client to track down a missing singer.
Every clue drags him deeper into New Orleans’ underworld—voodoo rituals, violent deaths, and a trail of secrets soaked in sin. At the center of it all is Epiphany, the singer’s mysterious daughter, floating through the story like a spell that slowly tightens around his soul. Then comes that reveal, and suddenly Epiphany’s name feels less poetic and more prophetic. Everything snaps into place, and you realize she wasn’t just part of the mystery… she was the key.
Epiphany Proudfoot is a character born from scandal, wrapped in mysticism, and sealed in cinematic legend. Lisa Bonet didn’t just break free with Angel Heart; she burned her old image to the ground and rose from the ashes in a cloud of smoke, blood, and divine rebellion. It’s a shame Bill Cosby blacklisted her; she was clearly far more interesting than that show ever allowed her to be.
56. Sheila (Rosalind Cash) | The Omega Man (1971)
Richard Matheson’s I Am Legend has been adapted multiple times, but The Omega Man is the strangest, boldest, and most disco-era of them all. First came The Last Man on Earth (1964), a bleak, gray, science-driven nightmare. Then in 1971, The Omega Man cranked the color, politics, and attitude to eleven. Decades later, I Am Legend (2007) would swing back to seriousness, loneliness, and moody apocalypse vibes.
But here’s the thing: only The Omega Man gives us Sheila, and that alone makes it the most unhinged and fascinating version of the story. In this world, a biological plague has wiped out most of humanity. Charlton Heston plays Neville, a lone immune survivor living in a deserted Los Angeles, fending off a cult-like group of infected “Family” members who want him dead because he represents the old world of science and technology. Until Sheila walks into the movie and instantly becomes its heartbeat. Sheila is not the passive survivor girl you’d expect.
She’s bold, outspoken, politically aware, and emotionally fearless. Where Neville is rigid, lonely, and clinging to the past, Sheila is alive, warm, and forward-thinking. She doesn’t just fall into his arms, though. She challenges him, questions his worldview, and dares him to imagine a future that isn’t built on guns, barricades, and nostalgia for dead systems.
Compared to the women in the other adaptations, Sheila is practically revolutionary. In The Last Man on Earth, the female characters are tragic, quiet, and doomed. In I Am Legend, the women function mostly as symbols of hope or loss. But Sheila? Sheila has agency. She argues. She laughs. She flirts. She pushes back. She refuses to exist only to reflect the male lead’s sadness. And that’s why she still feels so radical to this day. She’s not there to be saved; she’s there to reshape the world. In a film about extinction and fear, Sheila, more than Neville, represents hope.
55. Lucie Jurin (Mylène Jampanoï) | Martyrs (2008)
Martyrs is not a movie you “watch.” It is a movie that grabs you by the soul, drags you into a concrete basement, and exposes you to the worst shit imaginable. But that’s the point. It’s the only film within the torture porn subgenre to actually ask you, “Was this worth it?” It is designed to push your buttons but also pushes back and questions why you wanted them pushed in the first place. Of all the New French Extremity films, it is easily the most brutal, which means its final girl is, by default, the most resilient in film history. Lucie escaped captivity as a child, the sole survivor of a secret torture ring. Years later, still tormented by hallucinations and trauma, she tracks down the family she believes was responsible. She storms their perfectly normal suburban home like a woman possessed, convinced that killing them is the only way to make the pain stop. Naturally, things go from “unsettling” to “oh no” in under five minutes.
But Lucie isn’t a slasher villain—she’s a walking wound. She’s driven by fear, guilt, and a desperate need for closure, even as her mind is clearly unraveling. The film follows her and her friend Anna as the truth behind her suffering is slowly uncovered—and when it is, the story pivots into something even more horrifying, revealing a secret society obsessed with martyrdom and the afterlife. Lucie is the emotional spark that lights the fuse. She is frantic, volatile, and painfully human—like a cornered animal who only knows how to fight because no one ever taught her how to feel safe. What she goes through is beyond what any other horror character is subjected to. Even if you combined the final girl of every slasher and took their collective trauma and put it into one person, it still wouldn’t come close to the horrors Lucie has gone through. In Martyrs, pain isn’t just part of the story—it IS the story. And Lucie? She is its bleeding heart that refuses to stop beating.
54. Leah (Gaby Hoffmann) | Lyle (2014)
If Rosemary’s Baby got a Brooklyn lease, a queer best friend, and a severe case of emotional burnout, you’d get Lyle. Stewart Thorndike’s 2014 indie horror takes Polanski’s paranoia blueprint and filters it through grief, queer motherhood, and that very specific terror known as “my neighbors are definitely up to something.” At the center of this slow-burn descent is Leah—played by Gaby Hoffmann like a woman held together by caffeine, denial, and sheer will. The plot starts with a tragedy that shatters Leah’s world: her infant son dies suddenly, under mysterious circumstances. She and her partner June move into a new apartment building hoping for a fresh start, but instead they find whispered secrets, unsettling neighbors, and a strange cult-like group lurking in the shadows.
As Leah begins to suspect her child’s death was part of something far more sinister, everyone around her—friends, neighbors, even June—starts treating her like she’s losing her mind. Leah is a grief-fueled detective of doom. She doesn’t have a weapon, a plan, or a therapist who actually listens—but she has intuition and an unshakable belief that something is wrong. Is she actually the victim of gaslighting, or are they coincidences her fragile mind is creating a conspiracy around? Lyle is a low-key horror film that generates terror from vulnerability. Even if Leah is “crazy”, she’s a victim of her own mind, which is sometimes the scariest place of all.
53. Devil Doctor (Pītā) | Guinea Pig: Devil Woman Doctor (1986)
The VHS era was the last time a film could be infamous for violence. Not just because of the content within the movie itself, some of which was so morally reprehensible that they were literally banned, but because of the tactile nature of the VHS tape itself. There’s something seedy about a VHS tape. Something about the look of it, the sound of it rewinding, or the association you make at the sight of one with the fact that you know deep in your heart, many awful, unspeakable atrocities have been shot with a film camera. The very act of putting a VHS tape into your player and pushing play made every movie just 15% more real. That’s why we all believed the Faces of Death films were authentic and why only the most hardcore of horror fans searched out the Guinea Pig films. The first two and Mermaid in a Manhole are so infamous that no one talks about Android of Notre Dame or Guinea Pig: Devil Woman Doctor.
This is why I had zero idea that this franchise produced a legit horror comedy anthology movie. Each vignette presents a new “patient,” a new scenario, and a new excuse to push practical effects artists to their absolute limits. One segment focuses on surgical torture, another leans into grotesque sexual power games, while others feel like demented punchlines built entirely around how far a human body can be pushed before it stops resembling one. It’s splatter humor crossed with body humor mixed with gross-out gags hosted by the titular Devil Doctor Woman. Played by a drag performer named Pītā, the devil doctor is hilariously camp in her mannerisms and is utterly delighted by the carnage and mayhem around her. In a series filled with nothing but torture, she’s a ray of comedic sunshine.
52. Casey (Anna Cobb) | We’re All Going to the World’s Fair (2021)
If you’ve ever fallen down a late-night YouTube rabbit hole and thought, “This feels illegal, but emotionally,” then you already understand We’re All Going to the World’s Fair. Jane Schoenbrun’s lo-fi horror fairy tale is less about monsters and more about what happens when the internet becomes your only friend. At the center of this digital purgatory is Casey, a lonely teenager who lives in her bedroom, filming herself for a tiny online audience that may or may not even exist. She takes part in the “World’s Fair Challenge,” an internet ritual where you say a phrase, prick your finger, and then wait for something to “change.” After the challenge, Casey begins posting eerie video updates—claiming her body and mind are transforming. Are they real? Is she roleplaying? Is she spiraling? Or is this the only way she knows how to feel seen?
The film unfolds entirely through screens, webcams, and glitchy uploads, making you feel like you’ve hacked into someone’s diary at 3 a.m. Casey isn’t possessed—she’s just desperately lonely, and Anna Cobb plays her with heartbreaking awkwardness: fidgety, soft-spoken, eyes always scanning for validation. She’s trying on identities like filters, hoping one of them will finally stick. And the “horror” isn’t that she might be changing—it’s that no one is there to notice whether she is or not. We’re All Going to the World’s Fair is not a typical horror film. It’s never scary and by the time the third act rolls around, it’s clear jump scares and body horror were never the purpose. This is horror by way of Internet isolation. The scariest thing in the digital age isn’t what’s haunting us—it’s how alone we are when it does.
51. Victoria Heyes (Samantha Scaffidi) | Terrifier 2 (2022) & Terrifier 3 (2023)
The Terrifier movies are what happens when slasher horror drinks ten energy drinks and decides subtlety is for cowards. They are loud, outrageous, and deliberately over-the-top. Art the Clown is the closest thing we have to a modern horror icon, but he’s not the only character from this franchise that should’ve become a massive star. The Little Pale Girl (Amelie McLain) from Terrifier 2 has definitely gotten some traction with cosplayers thanks to her costume looking similar to Art’s, but it’s the body of her last victim that should be far more popular. In the original Terrifier, Victoria Heyes is one of Art’s victims who survives the night—physically alive, but deeply traumatized.
By the time Terrifier 2 begins, she’s in a psychiatric hospital, unable to speak, barely functioning, and completely haunted by what she endured. And then Terrifier 3 decides to put her through the wringer one more time by having her get possessed by the same demonic entity that conjured The Little Pale Girl. She started as a survivor who then became part of the nightmare itself. Her connection to Art deepens in ways that blur the line between victim, vessel, and something far darker. It is never explained who this demonic force is or why it wants to help Art, but whatever it is, it clearly has as much fun torturing and tormenting people as he does. It’s rare to see a final girl transform into a monster by the end of their arc, which makes Victoria Heyes as special and unique as she is brutally unhinged.
50. Pirita (Mirjami Kuosmanen) | The White Reindeer (1952)
Long before “elevated horror” became a marketing term, The White Reindeer was already serving prestige folklore wrapped around a tragic morality play. This Finnish classic blends fairy tale, tragedy, and monster movie into one hypnotic snowstorm with a central lead performance that would get Oscar buzz if it were made today… and if the Academy were cool with werewolf movies involving reindeer.
Pirita is a young Sámi woman married to a reindeer herder who is constantly away. She is emotionally abandoned in the most beautiful, frozen wasteland imaginable. Desperate to keep her husband’s love, she visits a shaman for help. The “love spell” backfires, and Pirita is cursed to transform into a white reindeer at night, luring men into the wilderness and killing them.
By day, she’s gentle, fragile, and deeply ashamed. By night, she’s a glowing, mythic creature roaming the snow, unable to satisfy her newfound bloodlust. She doesn’t want to hurt anyone, though; she just wants to be loved. And now she’s trapped between two worlds: wife by daylight, legend by moonlight. Pirita is the original snow queen of sad-girl horror. She’s heartbreak wrapped in fur, desire frozen into folklore, and proof that sometimes the real monster is loneliness… with antlers.
49. Aunt Mei (Bai Ling) | Dumplings (2004)
Before it became a full-length cult classic, Dumplings began life as part of the Hong Kong horror anthology Three… Extremes (2004), a showcase of elegant nightmares from Asia’s most daring directors. Audiences were so horrified, fascinated, and emotionally unwell by Fruit Chan’s segment that it expanded into its own feature. The people demanded more from Aunt Mei and her dumplings, and the film gave them all they could eat—and then some. Aunt Mei runs a very exclusive “wellness” business. Her specialty? Dumplings that promise youth, beauty, and fertility. The catch? The secret ingredient is deeply illegal, profoundly immoral, and absolutely not FDA-approved.
Enter Mrs. Li, a wealthy, aging socialite desperate to keep her cheating husband’s attention. When she becomes one of Aunt Mei’s clients, the film slides into a spiral of obsession, secrecy, and the cost of beauty. The Substance was just a week of shots and that ruined the main character’s life within half a year. The secret ingredient in these dumplings is far more insidious, which makes their decisions that much more horrific. Aunt Mei is chilling because she is so normal about everything. She cooks, she chats, she offers tea—like your favorite auntie if your favorite auntie also trafficked in nightmare fuel. Bai Ling plays her with a deadpan delivery, as if selling forbidden flesh is no different than selling herbal soup. She isn’t manic, she isn’t cruel—she’s just very good at her job. And that’s the real horror. Aunt Mei doesn’t force anyone to eat her dumplings. She simply provides what people already want: youth, desire, control. She is capitalism in an apron, a black-market fairy godmother who turns vanity into a blood contract.
48. Pannochka (Natalya Varley) | Viy (1967)
Viy is the most goth thing to ever come out of the USSR that wasn’t a Depeche Mode bootleg. Adapted from Nikolai Gogol’s story, it’s a folk-horror fever dream full of flying coffins, horny monks, demonic eyeliner, and one absolutely lethal brunette with bangs.
Enter Pannochka, who looks like she stepped out of a haunted perfume ad and into your nightmares. She first appears as a mysterious young woman living alone on a farm. A wandering seminary student named Khoma Brut (the human equivalent of “I can fix her”) ends up spending the night there. She seduces him, then—SURPRISE—turns into a witch, jumps on his back, and literally rides him through the night sky like a cursed Uber. Eventually Khoma fights back, beats her with a stick, and she collapses—appearing dead.
That “dead” woman is actually the daughter of a wealthy landowner, and Khoma is forced to spend three nights praying over her body in a church. Because in folk horror, when you kill a witch, the reward is…more witch. And this is where Pannochka becomes a full icon. By day she’s a tragic, pale beauty in a coffin, all soft curls and porcelain skin. By night? She is pure malice in lashes. She rises from the dead, summons demons, flies around the church, claws at the protective chalk circle like a feral monster, and finally calls in Viy himself—a grotesque demon king with an army of ghouls to finally get retribution on Khoma. He may be the lead, but Pannochka is the centerpiece—part ghost, part succubus, part Slavic drag queen of the damned. She walked so every spooky brunette in horror could float.
47. Arezoo Rahimi (Zar Amir Ebrahimi) | Holy Spider (2022)
Arezoo Rahimi is the kind of reporter who doesn’t just dig for truth… she excavates it with a jackhammer. Smart, relentless, and done with excuses, she arrives in Mashhad, Iran, chasing a story that’s as dark as her coffee and three times as unpleasant. There’s a serial killer targeting sex workers in the city. The police are sluggish, judgmental, and more interested in literally doing anything else other than solving crimes. Arezoo smells a cover-up and takes it upon herself to investigate the murders of these “invisible dead.” Thus begins her hunt for facts, for justice, and to expose what everyone else would rather ignore.
Zar Amir Ebrahimi brings Arezoo to life with fiery precision that’s equal parts steely journalist and exasperated human being tired of having to fight to get some justice for these slain prostitutes. Most movies about reporters chasing serial killers focus on the danger of them getting further and further into the underside of whatever seedy city they’ve chosen as their hunting ground, but in Holy Spider, Arezoo struggles to even get the green light to start in the first place. It’s a frustrating story that tries to juggle one too many balls, but as a character piece? It’s enormously captivating. Oh, and the story is based on a true story. So not only is she a superhero in the movie, she’s one in real life too.
46. Bakeneko / Old Woman (Fujie Satsuki) | Black Cat Mansion (1958)
Black Cat Mansion, a.k.a. Ankokukan no onna, is a lush, shadow-drenched ghost story where grief, greed, and generational trauma move into a cursed estate. The film follows a family who inherits a massive, spooky mansion from a recently deceased patriarch. Of course, instead of selling it and moving to Tokyo like sensible people, they decide to live there.
Bad idea.
Enter: the Old Woman. Quiet, hunched, unsettling, and obviously no good. She is not loud. She is not flashy. She is the kind of creepy that just exists in the background like a ghost with a pulse. The second she’s introduced, strange things start happening. Family members die mysteriously, people see shadows moving on their own, and a black cat keeps popping up like it’s a celebrity cameo.
And then the house’s past is slowly revealed: the old man who built it abused and murdered women, including the mother of a young girl who now lives there. The Old Woman? She is the ghostly caretaker—and also a bakeneko, a supernatural cat spirit born from rage, injustice, and the inability to move on. Basically: trauma + time + cat = revenge demon. Like all bakeneko, she’s not just haunting people for fun. She is vengeance on four paws, punishing the bloodline of a cruel man who thought he could bury his sins in a big house and call it luxury. She is part grieving mother, part cat demon, and is proof that grudges age like wine, curses have generational plans, and cats…cats remember everything.
45. Piper (Sora Wang) | Bring Her Back (2025)
Bring Her Back will live forever in the minds of horror fans, thanks to Sally Hawkins’ unforgettable performance. In an alternate reality where Aunt Gladys (Amy Madigan) from Weapons doesn’t exist, Hawkins definitely would’ve been nominated for an Oscar. They’re both worthy of award attention, but the Academy was only ever going to nominate one since they hate the genre and Madigan makes more sense. It’s a bigger, more immediately iconic performance. Hawkins is subtle, whereas Madigan goes for theatricality. They’re both the stars of their movies, but the child victim caught in both of their malevolent webs ends up quietly stealing the show. In Weapons, it’s a young boy named Alex (Cary Christopher) who has to deal with an evil witch, and in Bring Her Back, it’s a young blind girl named Piper who has to battle a grieving mother who wants to use witchcraft to resurrect her deceased daughter.
Set in a grief-soaked household that hums with bad vibes and worse intentions, Bring Her Back follows two siblings trying to survive a foster situation that feels less “found family” and more “Welcome to the cult, please remove your soul.” Piper is blind, yes—but she is not fragile. She navigates the world through sound, touch, and instinct, and those instincts are screaming that something is deeply wrong. Their foster mom feels too friendly and her son feels too off. The vibes, as the kids say, are off. Piper’s brother becomes her anchor, her translator to a world that pretends not to see her while simultaneously underestimating her at every turn. Their bond is the film’s heartbeat—two kids clinging to each other while everything else spirals into ritualistic, psychological hell. While the world is busy throwing flowers at Hawkins (as it should, she’s a legend), Piper stands there in defiance. She’s not the type of character you buy merch for or nominate for Oscars, but she’s the type of character the genre is in desperate need of. Strong, smart, and capable children who aren’t annoying and who can hold their own against legendary actors.
44. Laura Franco (Melissa Barrera) | Your Monster (2024)
In Your Monster, Laura starts the movie already wrecked: she’s recovering from serious illness, her long-term boyfriend dumps her, and then—just to really twist the knife—he takes the musical she helped build and turns it into his own career glow-up. So naturally, she retreats to her childhood home, the sacred place where old wounds go to stretch their legs. And that’s when she finds… a literal monster in her closet. Not a metaphor. A real, growly, fur-covered, emotionally opinionated creature who lives between her winter coats. And instead of screaming and running, Laura does the most Laura thing possible: she talks to him. Argues with him. Slowly forms the weirdest roommate relationship since The Odd Couple, but with claws.
The monster becomes her hype beast, her rage translator, and her personal cheerleader for reclaiming her life. He pushes her to stop shrinking, stop apologizing, and stop letting men write her out of her own story. What makes Laura such a joy to watch is how real she feels. She’s not “strong” in a polished, movie-trailer way—she’s awkward, bitter, funny, vulnerable, and quietly furious. Melissa Barrera plays her like someone who’s been holding it together with duct tape and show tunes, and the tape is finally peeling. By the time the story hits its emotional peak, it’s clear: the monster isn’t just a creature in the closet. He’s Laura’s suppressed anger, ambition, and voice—finally allowed to take up space. Your Monster, like Lisa Frankenstein, feels like it’ll be the next generation’s favorite little weirdo love story.
43. Jill Johnson (Carol Kane) | When a Stranger Calls Back (1993)
In the original When a Stranger Calls, Jill is a college babysitter who receives creepy phone calls asking, “Have you checked the children?” The twist: the calls were coming from inside the house, from a man who murdered the children who were sleeping upstairs. Jill survives, but her innocence doesn’t, with her walking away with her nervous system permanently set to “danger mode.” And that’s where When a Stranger Calls Back begins.
Years later, Jill is trying to live a normal life. She’s married, she’s settled, she’s doing that brave post-trauma thing where you pretend you’re fine but avoid dark staircases as you owe them money. But then a local teenage girl is attacked by a man who mimics voices and disguises himself to get inside houses.
The police bring Jill in as a consultant because apparently she is now the city’s leading expert in weird serial killers. The more Jill helps, the more she realizes something horrifying: this new predator isn’t just similar to her old nightmare—he’s repeating it. And once again, Jill becomes the target. But this time, she’s ready. Carol Kane doesn’t play Jill as a standard scream queen. She plays her like a woman who has already lived through hell and refuses to let it win twice. She’s nervous, but also observant, sharp, and quietly determined.
Jill doesn’t collapse under fear. She weaponizes it. Unlike future scream queens who become badass by turning into the Terminator, she’s badass by simply not allowing fear to ever beat her again. Where the first movie was about terror entering her life, this one is about her learning how to confront it. She goes from passive victim to active survivor, using what she learned from the past to stop history from repeating itself. Jill Johnson is the final girl who grew up, paid her trauma taxes, and still showed up to save someone else.
42. Dezzy (Dora Madison) | Bliss (2019)
If self-destruction were an art medium, Dezzy would be working in oil, neon, and regret. Her character in Bliss has one of the messiest, sweatiest, blood-splattered spirals in modern horror. She is a struggling painter in L.A. whose art career is tanking, her relationship is collapsing, and her inspiration has packed its bags and moved to a different dimension. Her dealer (who is also somehow her emotional support system) offers her a mysterious new drug, and like a dumbass, she decides to take it. The drug hits like divine lightning. Suddenly Dezzy can paint again. Her work explodes into violent, abstract masterpieces. She feels unstoppable. Euphoric. Reborn. But since this is a horror movie, there’s obviously a side effect: blood.
As her need for the drug grows, so does her hunger for something darker. Nights blur into hallucinatory chaos as she tears through the city, chasing inspiration, oblivion, and the next hit—no matter the cost. Dezzy isn’t a “tragic” artist. She’s a gremlin with a paintbrush, powered by desperation, addiction, and a broken heart. She’s not glamorous. She’s not noble. She’s ugly in the most honest way possible. The film doesn’t romanticize her spiral, but traps you inside it until you feel like you also need a shower and an exorcism.
Dezzy becomes the ultimate metaphor for creative obsession: how far will you go to make something “real”? What are you willing to sacrifice for your art? In her case: everything. Including herself. Dezzy is the patron saint of bad choices, neon nightmares, and talent that burns too hot to survive its own body.
41. Lady Mary Van Tassel (Miranda Richardson) | Sleepy Hollow (1999)
In Tim Burton’s Sleepy Hollow, fog is a personality trait, trees and buildings look like they’ve been designed by Edward Gorey, and everything else looks like it fell into an inkwell. At the center of this baroque nightmare stands Lady Mary Van Tassell—a woman who proves that the most dangerous thing in Sleepy Hollow is not a headless ghost on a horse, but a woman with a plan, a corset, and generational rage. At first glance, Lady Mary is the very definition of colonial respectability: quiet, pious, long-suffering, and devoted. She appears to be the obedient second wife of the town’s richest man, Baltus Van Tassel. Everyone underestimates her. Everyone forgets her. Which, of course, is exactly how she wants it. The film follows Ichabod Crane (Johnny Depp), a jittery New York constable sent to investigate a string of beheadings in the cursed town of Sleepy Hollow.
The locals insist the killer is the Headless Horseman, a mercenary ghost summoned from the grave to collect heads on command. Ichabod, armed with science, fear, and Johnny Depp cheekbones, tries to uncover the truth behind the murders. What Ichabod doesn’t realize is that he is not chasing a monster—he is being led by one. What makes Lady Mary such a compelling villain is that she is both monstrous and tragically human. Her rage is earned, her suffering real—but her response is absolute annihilation. She is not content with justice; she wants domination. She doesn’t just want to survive—she wants to erase everyone who made her small. Turning the beloved and iconic story into a murder mystery makes this the most unique adaptation, and having the twist be that Lady Mary is behind them, makes it the best.
80-61 | 40-21
Who do you think are some of the most underrated female characters in horror movies? Maybe they will show up later on this list!
The official ScreenAge Newsletter has arrived! Subscribe to receive a semi-regular round-up of all our exclusive content, including reviews, editorials, Top 100 lists, and more! C'mon, we know you want to venture further into the Wasteland with us!
